Are high-priced carry-on suitcases a justified investment?
In the world of travel, the suitcase you choose can significantly impact the enjoyment of your holiday. CHOICE, a renowned expert in consumer advocacy, has conducted a comprehensive review of more than 30 carry-on and check-in suitcases from brands like Antler, Samsonite, American Tourister, and Kmart.
According to Kim Gilmour, a CHOICE expert, the key differences between cheap and expensive carry-on suitcases lie in weight, style/features, and durability.
Weight: Expensive carry-ons, such as the Rimowa Essential Lite Cabin, weigh as little as 4.9 pounds due to lightweight, durable materials like polycarbonate. Cheaper suitcases tend to be heavier and may not use advanced lightweight materials.
Style and Features: Premium suitcases often boast sleek, minimalist or iconic designs, luxury linings, multiple compartments, extra pockets, locking mechanisms, and smooth-rolling wheels. For instance, Rimowa carry-ons feature a streamlined butterfly-style opening and well-organized compartments. Some affordable sets, like LEVEL8, offer smart features such as external laptop pockets, which is uncommon for their price.
Durability: While many cheap suitcases can survive basic drop and drag tests, more expensive ones use higher-quality materials and technology that tend to last longer and come with extended warranties (up to 10 years), offering replacements or repairs. Premium brands invest more in corner reinforcements, stronger shells, sturdy handles, and high-quality zippers, contributing to longevity and dependability during rough handling.
In summary, expensive carry-on suitcases usually deliver lighter weight, more refined styling with advanced features, and greater durability, including longer warranty protection. Cheaper ones may suffice for occasional travel but often lack the premium materials, design, and service that justify higher price points.
Other benefits of pricier suitcases include a TSA lock that allows you to lock your luggage while permitting security authorities to inspect it without damage. They also offer a variety of colors, styles, and sizes, making it easier for you to find a case that suits your personal taste.
Choosing a suitcase that is easy to move and durable is crucial for stress-free travel. Shopping around can help find a suitcase at a price well below the recommended retail price (RRP). Good deals can be found during sales such as Black Friday, Boxing Day, or end-of-financial-year sales.
Members of CHOICE can access all expert, independent reviews. Non-members can jump straight to the results of the best products. The majority of suitcases tested scored a perfect 100% in the 'lift and drop' test, indicating they came out unscathed. However, it's worth noting that tested suitcases under $100 from Kmart and Big W did not include the TSA lock feature.
If a suitcase is old and worn out, it may need to be replaced, which can be a financial burden. Therefore, investing in a durable, high-quality suitcase could save you money in the long run.
Matthew Tung, a CHOICE luggage tester, emphasised the importance of considering the luggage you take on holiday. A brightly-colored or distinctive case is easier to spot in a sea of luggage at the baggage terminal, ensuring a smoother journey for you. The $39 Kmart carry-on, plus return flights from Sydney to Melbourne, costs less than the most expensive suitcases in the test.
In conclusion, while it may be tempting to opt for a cheaper suitcase, investing in a more expensive, high-quality model could provide you with a more enjoyable, stress-free travel experience.
- A more expensive suitcase often comes with terms and conditions offering extended warranties, which could potentially save you money in the long run if the suitcase needs repairs or replacements.
- Choosing a lifestyle-focused suitcase, such as those offering distinctive designs or TSA locks, can provide added convenience during travel, making it easier for you to find your luggage and protect your belongings.
